Sky Atlas 2000.0 Second Edition
by Tom Polakis
Sky Atlas 2000.0 Second Edition
by Wil Tirion and Roger Sinnott
Sky Publishing, $49.95
Veteran sky watchers may remember the introduction of Wil Tirion's "Sky
Atlas 2000.0" in 1981. At the time it was revolutionary, being the first
star atlas to use Equinox 2000 coordinates. Inside a bound package
measuring 11" by 16" were 26 charts covering the sky at a scale of 7.8mm
per degree. The only suitable competition was Antonin Becvar's "Atlas of
the Heavens," which over the years had revealed problems in need of repair.
With its sweeping improvements, Tirion's work became the replacement for
its predecessor, and took over as the standard intermediate-scale star
atlas. 17 years later, the Second Edition of "Sky Atlas 2000.0" has been
released. Its improvements on a classic are no less impressive than those
we witnessed in 1981.
The second edition also employs 26 charts, but at a slightly increased
scale of 8.2mm per degree. The dimensions of the atlas thus increase by 1
1/2" in width and 3/4" in height to provide identical sky coverage on each
chart. As with the first edition, the atlas is available in the Deluxe
Version, in which objects are plotted in color on a white background, and
the less expensive black-and-white Desk and Field editions. The Desk and
Field editions represent the sky a smaller scale of 7.1mm per degree.
At first glance the most desirable change in the second edition is its
depiction of stars. The first edition plotted roughly 43,000 stars down to
magnitude 8.0. This quantity is nearly doubled with the new edition's
magnitude limit of 8.5. Much has happened in the star cataloguing business
since 1981, and this is used to advantage by authors Wil Tirion and Roger
Sinnott. Most significantly, the second edition employs the
Hipparcos/Tycho star catalogues, which results in improved accuracy in
stellar positions and brightnesses. Star symbols are plotted in a
continuous range of sizes -- a big improvement on the whole-magnitude steps
of the first edition. The increases in both depth and resolution should
prove helpful to the observer intent on locating faint galaxies in sparse
star fields.
For the deep-sky enthusiast, the second edition is vastly improved. The
number of objects is only modestly increased from 2500 to 2700, but the
selection criteria are more consistent. Fans of dull open clusters may be
disappointed to learn that many of these objects were dropped from the
database if they didn't meet the strict criteria for inclusion in the
atlas. Galaxies are plotted as ellipses in their correct position angles.
Dark nebulae from the catalogues of Barnard and Lynds are included, and
large ones are plotted to scale. Milky Way contours are plotted in four
levels rather than two. The transparent coordinate overlay presents a
finer grid, and even includes the bullseye pattern of the popular 1-power
Telrad finder.
It was irresistible to lay the first and second editions side by side. I
found Chart #22 to be a suitable page for comparing the two editions.
Centered on Sagittarius and Scorpius, this particular region of the sky can
be prone to clutter. Less worthy cartographers than Wil Tirion have often
met their demise in attempting to render this rich section of the sky.
Inclusion of prominent dark nebulae in the second edition means that the
Pipe Nebula so familiar to modern observers is shown in all its glory.
Bright nebulae such as NGC 6334 that were simply "green boxes" in the first
edition are outlined in correct shapes. The number of open clusters is
glaringly reduced; for example the Stinger of Scorpius now contains 7,
instead of 12, plotted open clusters. All planetary nebulae are labeled
with NGC/IC or Perek-Kohoutek (PK) designations. Gone are planetary nebula
designations such as Sp 1. While I didn't set out hunting for corrections
from the first edition, they too been cleaned up. M24 correctly points to
the small Sagittarius star cloud rather than a small open cluster in the
vicinity. On another chart, the Vela Supernova Remnant is labeled as such,
and not mistaken for the nearby Gum Nebula.
We find another good comparison by opening the two atlases to Chart #2. In
the bowl of the Big Dipper, the multitude of faint galaxies will certainly
be more easy to locate knowing their correct orientations on the sky and
hopping from 8.5-magnitude finding stars. Over 200 star names are now
included in the second edition. How many people would have known that
Lambda and Mu Ursae Majoris are also known as Tania Borealis and Tania
Australis? The double star catalogued as M40 has been plotted for those
who feel compelled to complete the Messier list. All deep-sky objects are
now labeled; the giant planetary nebula PK 164+31.1 in Lynx is an example.
General improvements in appearance are also laudable. The many lines and
curves of celestial coordinates have a cleaner feel. The garish
constellation boundaries of the first edition no longer get in your way and
legends are more readable. Chart numbers are now accessible without
folding out the page. And the confusing practice of the first edition of
using a star-like dot to delimit different designations of the same object
has been abandoned. All of these changes help when viewing chart under
dim, red light.
Two brand new additions that appear in the second edition are Charts A and
B, which feature selected areas as 2 1/2 times the scale of the other
charts, and plot stars down to magnitude 10.5. The selected areas are
great choices, featuring the fields of both celestial poles, the Virgo
galaxy cluster, Orion, the Pleiades, and two high-proper motion stars.
Again, these charts are a joy to peruse by day, somewhat like scanning over
an inset map of your city in a road atlas of the country.
It is difficult to have any gripes with the second edition of "Sky Atlas
2000.0," but I do have one big one. I consider the backs of the charts to
be a vast expanse of untapped space. I wished the authors would have taken
a lead from Tirion's excellent, smaller-scale "Bright Star Atlas," and used
the facing pages to provide catalogue data for all of the plotted objects.
Perhaps it would have bumped the price up by another ten bucks, but it
could have made this the end-all atlas of its scale. It would be a nice
gesture for Tirion and Sinnott's to make their database available as a
diskette or on-line, even if only as an ASCII text file.
Will I use the second edition of "Sky Atlas 2000.0" in the field? Well,
no. I've discovered the joys of using a laptop computer and charting
software at the telescope, and the advantages outweigh anything that a
paper atlas could ever accomplish. Still, "Sky Atlas 2000.0" is a great
enough piece of work to be enjoyed at the desk. For fifty bucks, there is
enough in these charts to keep most observers occupied for a lifetime.